Human Sacrifice in Aztec Culture

We know about human sacrifice in Aztec culture from an array evidence. First of all, we have prehispanic codices that have survived. In those pictorial manuscripts we see many scenes of sacrifice, both human sacrifice and the sacrifice of gods. Secondly, we have interviews that took place between Spanish priests and indigenous Aztecs during the conquest of Mexico wherein we have many accounts of sacrificial rituals. The most impressive empirical record comes from “The Florentine Codex”, which is currently in the Laurentian library in Florence. These are interviews that took place in Mexico city between 1540 and 1580. We have detailed descriptions of ritual sequences of the 18 ceremonies where human sacrifice took place.

Thirdly, we have eyewitnesses’ accounts of the Spaniards who saw the sacrifices taking place, sometimes sacrifices of Spaniards by Aztecs. Archeology is the fourth source. In the archeological record we have the remains of people who were sacrificed, and we have proof that they were sacrificed – the marks on their skeleton. Moreover, we have sculptures that show sacrifice, and we have other kinds of ritual objects used in sacrifice. So, there are 4 main sources: pictorial manuscripts, eyewitness accounts, interviews and the actual Aztec archeology.

What we call the Aztecs only existed between 1325 and 1525. That is the historic period of Aztec sacrifices. Ritual human sacrifices were practiced well before the Aztecs came into the valley of Mexico in the first part of the 14th century. There are strong indications that the ritual killing of people and animals took place in the second millennium BCE. One aspect which distinguishes the Aztec period sacrifices was an escalation of ritual human sacrifice. We see the escalation of sacrifice from about 1440 to about 1521 beginning when the first Moctezuma comes into power. He reigned for many years, and during his time the empire expanded. One interesting parallel is that as the empire expands, the size of the Great Aztec Temple also expands and human sacrifice increases. That is the period of time that we are talking about today.

We do not know exactly who invented human sacrifice, but in Mesoamerican records before the Aztecs we have the Toltecs. The Toltecs were from about 900 to 1200 AD. And they had human sacrifice. Prior to and during this Toltec period there were sacrifices among the Maya and in the great imperial capital of Teotihuacan in central Mesoamerica. So human sacrifice was a widespread practice in Mesoamerica from very early on in the rise of urban civilization.

As an Aztec state sponsored ritual practice, human sacrifice ends in the 1520’s. There are some records of a few sacrifices taking place after the Spaniards arrive, but the state sponsored ritual sacrifices end in the first ten years after the arrival of the Spaniards. Then the Spaniards replaced it with their own kind of violence. One scholar makes the comparison between Aztec and Spanish violence this way. The Aztecs built a sacrifice society while the Spaniards built a mass-sacrifice society.

The Aztec theology justified ritual human sacrifice in the following terms. Human bodies had two selves: there were a shell and a divine spark which was deposited by divinities at the time of conception. The gods and the universe they created needed to be periodically regenerated through the sacrifice and release of the divine sparks within the bodies of humans, plants, insects, animals. Death by normal or ritual means released the divine spark which descended into the earth, the underworld and collected a new shell or matter. When plants, the Sun, the Moon, animals or humans reappear on the surface of the earth they contain that recycled divine spark that continues to live on in a cycle of birth, death and rebirth. Blood is one of the carriers of this divine spark. In the Aztec world, everybody was involved in bloodletting. Blood was ‘let’ from lips, ears, and thighs with the most devout priests letting blood from tongues and even genitals. This is the theological justification.

The second purpose of the sacrifice was political. Many Aztec sacrifices took place for public viewing in order to show the religious legitimacy of the rulers and their military policies or the need to ensure agricultural fertility. In a few cases, the rulers of allied or enemy cities were brought to the capital to view the sacrifice of their own captured warriors.

Selection of the victim

An extraordinary example of how the Aztecs chose a person for sacrifice can be seen in the 5th month of the ritual calendar which was dedicated to both fertility and male beauty. They chose a person whom they considered to be the most handsome male. There is a wonderful description of how this person was chosen. They had a formula on this month of what the male sacrificial victim would look like. So what they did – they captured warriors and they kept them in a certain area and they looked for the best-looking one. We have a description:

“He was like something smooth, like a tomato, as if sculpted in wood. He was not curly-haired, he was not rough of forehead, he was not long-headed, he was not of swollen eyelids, he was not of enlarged eyelids, he was not flat-nosed, he did not have a nose with wide nostrils, he was not concave-nosed, he was not thick-lipped, he was not gross-lipped, he was not big-lipped, he was not a stutterer, he did not speak a barbarous language, he was not large-toothed…” It goes on and on like this about every aspect of his body: «He was not long-handed, he was not one-handed, he was not handless, he was not fat-fingered and it goes on, talks about the stomach. He had no blemish, he had no mark, he was taken the greatest care, and he would be taught to blow the flute, and he would be able to play his whistle. At the same time, he would hold all his flowers and his smoking tube”.

They were looking for a very good-looking man, according to their standard. They would take this person and teach him how to hold and work with flowers , how to play flutes, and how to speak Nahuatl, the Aztec language, in a sophisticated way. For one year he lived in the Aztec city as a god. He had been ritually transformed into a divine being and was given the best food, care and always traveled with an entourage including guards. According to one reliable source, he was given 4 divinized women for companionship and sexual acitivity as a way of regenerating the cosmos. Near the end, he was taken out of the island city and led to climb a small pyramid, breaking his flutes on the ascent and then he was sacrificed. Children and women were sacrificed in some of the other monthly rituals. We have detailed descriptions of these sacrifices as well.

What all this teaches us is that a sacrifice was seen as an honor. It was an elevation and while members of families were sad or disturbed by losing someone close, Aztec ideology labeled those who were sacrificed as divine beings whose death helped regenerate the cosmos.

David L. Carrasco